← All workResearch

Is there a junior penalty?

A working paper testing whether generative AI has cut demand for early-career software developers, using only US public data.

Role
Author
When
2026
Stack
PythonPandasDifference-in-differencesEvent studiesBLS OEWSCPS microdata
−54%

software job postings, late 2022 to mid 2026

58%

of the fall from peak came before ChatGPT

6

public datasets, fully reproducible

The question

Since ChatGPT’s release in November 2022, has generative AI reduced demand for junior software developers relative to seniors, in postings, employment or pay? I graduated into this market in 2026.

What the data says

  • Postings collapsed. Software postings on Indeed fell 54% from late 2022 to mid 2026, the most of 41 occupational categories. But 58% of the fall from the February 2022 peak happened before ChatGPT, alongside interest-rate hikes.
  • Employment did not. In BLS data, software developer and QA employment grew 8.3% from May 2022 to May 2025. Pay at the 10th percentile rose faster than at the 90th, so the wage distribution compressed.
  • Juniors kept their share. In CPS microdata, the share of developers aged 22 to 25 was essentially flat, ranking 102 of 222 occupations for change.
  • One source disagrees. Stack Overflow survey respondents report a junior-senior pay gap that widened 5 to 13% after 2022. It is the only source showing a pay penalty, and it is prone to selection.

Bottom line

Hiring demand for software work collapsed and tilted toward experience, but much of that predates ChatGPT. Representative data through mid-2026 shows no junior employment or wage penalty among employed developers yet.

A note on method

An early draft of this project used a synthetic postings panel. I removed it, rebuilt every result on public data, and published the replication package so each number in the paper can be regenerated.